Rating Every AL All-Star by Position

By: Jon

Last night, MLB selected the All-Stars for the 2013 All-Star game in New York. As usual, there are many questionable moves that have create quite a uproar. In this article, I will go through every position and analyze MLB’s decision.

AL

Catcher

Starter:

Joe Mauer

Joe Mauer
Joe Mauer

Good or Bad: Good

This was the easiest choice for the selection committee. The AL has some of the weakest catchers in the league. Mauer is having a solid season for the Twinkies, .312/8HR/30RBI. This will be Mauer sixth All-Star nomination and I expect many more in the future.

Reserves:

Juan Castro

Juan Castro
Juan Castro

Good or Bad: Good

As the best player on the Astros, he must be on the All-Star roster. Castro has the second highest WAR, among AL catchers. Although Castro does not have the RBI numbers, 30, he cannot be blamed because for the lack of men on base. Castro has hit 12 HR and batted .270.

Salvador Perez

Salvador Perez
Salvador Perez

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Josh Donaldson

Josh Donaldson
Josh Donaldson

Since every team must be represented at the All-Star game, some players, who would be undeserving, make the team. However, since I want Greg Holland to go, Perez will not be lucky enough to be nominated. This is Perez’s first of many All-Star games. Perez is the third best catcher in the AL. Besides for being a great catcher, he bats over .300 and has hit 4HR and 36 RBI. Donaldson is one of the more underrated players in the league. He is having a great season, 6th in the AL in WAR. Donaldson is deserving of an All-Star invitation because of his .319/15HR/57RBI/50R.

First Base

Starter:

Chris Davis

Chris Davis
Chris Davis

Good or Bad: Good

Although I do not believe that Chris Davis should have received the most All-Star votes, Davis has been the second best baseball player this year. Most players would love to have seasons like Davis’s first half. Although I do not expect Davis to continue his torrid pace of .324/64HR/160RBI/115Runs, he will put up great stats. This selection is legit.

Reserves:

Edwin Encarnacion

Edwin Encarnacion
Edwin Encarnacion

Good or Bad: Good

For the second straight year, Edwin is having a great season for the Toronto Blue Jays. Edwin is a RBI machine, knocking in 68 players and hitting in 23 HR. This will be Edwin’s first All-Star appearance. This definitely is a good selection.

Prince Fielder

Prince Fielder
Prince Fielder

Good or Bad: Good

Unlike the NL, the AL is pretty weak at the first base position. Even though Prince Fielder is not having a great season, he deserves to play in his fifth All-Star game. Prince is the fourth hitter for the best lineup in the majors. He is third RBI and fifth in HR, among AL first baseman.

Second Base

Starter:

Robinson Cano

Robinson Cano
Robinson Cano

Good or Bad: Good

This was the most difficult decision for the All-Star committee. Although Cano does not have the highest WAR, he is the only good hitter on the Yankees. Opposing pitchers do not have to pitch to Cano because the Yankee lineup is not deep or dangerous. Cano is leading AL second baseman in RBI, HR, and Slugging and the difference is not very close. Cano plays great defense as well.

Reserve:

Dustin Pedroia

Dustin Pedroia
Dustin Pedroia

Good or Bad: Good

This year, Pedroia has returned to his MVP form. Although Dustin does not have much power, 5 HR, he is leading second baseman in AVG, OPS, and WAR. He is the leader of the first place Boston Red Sox. Pedroia is one of the best leaders in baseball as well as one of the best defensive players.

Jason Kipnis

Jason Kipnis
Jason Kipnis

Good or Bad: Good

One month ago, Jason would not be even close to be on this list. Kipnis is top three in many offensive categories among second baseman. In June, Kipnis had a great month, .419/4HR/25RBI/9SB. This great mont, along with the success he experienced last year, made him a good All-Star selection.

Shortstop

Starter:

JJ Hardy

JJ Hardy
JJ Hardy

Good or Bad: Good selection, Bad starter

Hardy is a great defensive player with exceptional power for a shortstop. Hardy has the most HR, 15, and RBI, 46, among AL shortstops. He is a great defensive player, won the Gold Glove award last season. He is one of the defensive and offensive leaders for the Baltimore Orioles.

Reserve:

Jhonny Peralta

Jhonny Peralta
Jhonny Peralta

Good or Bad: Should have been starter

Jhonny Peralta is one of the most underrated shortstops in all of baseball. Peralta, although not a great defensive player, is an exceptional offensive player for one of the best offenses in baseball. Peralta is beating Hardy in AVG, OBP, SLG, OPS, and WAR. Thus he should be the starter for the All-Star game.

Third Base

Starter:

Miguel Cabrera

Miguel Cabrera
Miguel Cabrera

Good or Bad: Good

Currently the best hitter in MLB and one of the best hitters in MLB history, Cabrera may win the Triple Crown for the second straight year in a row, the first to accomplish this feat. Although not a great defensive player, Cabrera makes up for all his miscues by his great hitting.

Reserve:

Manny Machado

Manny Machado
Manny Machado

Good or Bad: Good

After watching Machado play two series against the Yankees, I am determined that he will be the best player in baseball at one time during his career. Machado has every tool and attribute a Hall of Famer must have. Although he is not playing his natural position, Machado is one of the best defensive third baseman in baseball. Although he does not have great power, 6HR, he is a double machine. He is on pace to set the MLB record for doubles in his first full season.

Outfield

Starters:

Mike Trout

Mike Trout
Mike Trout

Good or Bad: Good

Trout is the best all around player in baseball and he is only 21. Trout is leading AL outfielders in AVG, hits, Runs, OBP, and WAR. Although Trout started the season slowly, batting .261 in April, he has exploded since April and returned to his great stats and play. Currently there is no better outfielder in baseball so this was an easy choice

Adam Jones

Adam Jones
Adam Jones

Good or Bad: Good

The All-Star outfielder is having another good season for the Baltimore Orioles. Jones is one of the best power hitting outfielders in the American League. Jones is ranked top five in the AL in H, R, RBI, HR, and SLG. Along with his great power, Jones is fast which enables him to steal bases, 9, and play a great centerfield for Baltimore. This was a solid selection by the committee.

Jose Bautista

Jose Bautista
Jose Bautista

Good or Bad: Good

Although Bautista is not having his best season of his career, he is one of the best power hitters in the league. Although he does not have a great batting average, .261, he is top three in runs, home runs, slugging, on base percentage, and WAR. After Bautista, the AL outfielder position is weak so the Bautista decision is validated.

Reserve:

Nelson Cruz

Nelson Cruz
Nelson Cruz

Good or Bad: Good

Although Nelson is not a great defensive player nor a great average hitter, .275, he is a great power hitter, who can drive in a lot of runs. Besides for having the third best OPS, he has the most home runs and RBI in the AL as well as the second highest slugging. Cruz was deserving of an All-Star reserve spot.

Torii Hunter

Torii Hunter
Torii Hunter

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Daniel Nava

Daniel Nava
Daniel Nava

Although Torii Hunter is an all-time defensive player and a solid offensive player, he did not deserve to go to New York for the All-Star game. Although Hunter started the season hot, .370 AVG, his average significantly dipped to .309. Nava is an underrated player, who put up great stats for the Red Sox during the first half of the season. Nava has more HR, RBI, Runs, and a higher OPS, SLG, OPB, and WAR than Torii Hunter. As the stats depict, Nava has been a better player, during the first half of the season, than Torii Hunter.

Alex Gordon

Alex Gordon
Alex Gordon

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Jacoby Ellsbury

Jacoby Ellsbury
Jacoby Ellsbury

Although Gordon is a good baseball player, I believe that Jacoby Ellsbury is a better player and a better fit for the All-Star team. Gordon is a really good player, Gold Glove winner and accumulating .293/9HR/46RBI. Although Ellsbury does not have great power, he is a very good player because of his speed. Ellsbury is leading the league in steals, 36, while batting .301 and scored 55 runs. Ellsbury has a better WAR than Gordon, 3.1 vs 2.5. Although Ellsbury is not a slam dunk pick, I believe Gordon should have been replaced by Ellsbury.

Ben Zobrist

Ben Zobrist
Ben Zobrist

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Evan Longoria

Evan Longoria
Evan Longoria

This was the worst All-Star selection by far. Although Zobrist is a nice player, he is not deserving of an All-Star appearance. Zobrist has the 49th highest WAR in the American League, behind Brian Dozier, Aaron Hicks, and Eric Sogard. Zobrist’s stats are not impressive, .262/5HR/45RBI/45R. Longoria should have been on this All-Star team. Longoria is tied for the 9th highest WAR in the AL. Longoria plays great defense as well as a great offense player. Evan hit .289/17HR/49RBI/53R. Longoria should easily have been on this team.

Pitchers

Starting Pitchers:

Clay Buchholz

Clay Buchholz
Clay Buchholz

Good or Bad: Good

Although Clay has only pitched 84.1 innings and 12 games, he has been extremely effective. Although he has not pitched enough innings for his ERA to count, Clay has a 1.71 ERA and has not lost, 9-0. He will probably not be able to pitch in the game because of his back injury. However if he can pitch, he will definitely be deserving of this honor.

Bartolo Colon

Bartolo Colon
Bartolo Colon

Good or Bad: Good

Bartolo Colon has been extremely effective for the Oakland A’s this season. Colon has a 2.78 ERA, 11 wins, 3.1 WAR, and 1.10 WHIP. Although Colon is not a strikeout pitcher, Colon has used his great stuff and movement to get out batters. A’s should be thankful for Colon’s first half production because he will not be able to replicate his performance.

Yu Darvish

Yu Darvish
Yu Darvish

Good or Bad: Good

Darvish is one of the most dominant pitchers in the league based upon his strikeout totals. Darvish is leading the AL in strikeouts by 18 batters. Darvish is having a great season for the Texas Rangers, 3.02 ERA, 1.05 WHIP, and 3.2 WAR. Darvish has some of the best stuff in the league, which enables him to dominate hitters and be worthy of an All-Star appearance.

Felix Hernandez

Felix Hernandez
Felix Hernandez

Good or Bad: Good

Although Hernandez has been one of the best pitchers in the AL, he may not be having the best first half on his own team. Hernandez is tied for third in WAR, 3.8, eighth highest WHIP, 1.11, and the second lowest ERA, 2.69. Hernandez is fourth in strikeouts because of his dynamic fastball, curveball, and slider combination

Hisashi Iwakuma

Hisashi Iwakuma
Hisashi Iwakuma

Good or Bad: Good

Similar to Colon, Hisashi is not a strikeout pitcher, but he can be extremely effective. Iwakuma is leading the league in ERA and WHIP, while having the third best WAR. Hisashi is an experienced pitcher who causes hitters to make mistakes and swing at balls.

Justin Masterson

Justin Masterson
Justin Masterson

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Hiroki Kuroda

Hiroki Kuroda
Hiroki Kuroda

Although Masterson is a quality pitcher, he should not be on this All-Star squad. Neither Masterson’s ERA nor WHIP is impressive enough to be on the All-Star team. Masterson’s ERA is 3.78 while is WHIP is 1.22. Although Masterson has the third most strikeouts in the league, he has seven losses and is 19th among pitchers in WAR. Although Kuroda does not have the strikeout totals, Kuroda knows how to get out major league hitters. Kuroda is top eight in ERA, WHIP, GS, and WAR. He is much more deserving of the All-Star bid than Masterson.

Chris Sale

Chris Sale
Chris Sale

Good or Bad: Good

Sale should be the starting pitcher for the AL in the All-Star game. Although Sale only has 5 wins,  he is top five in strikeout, WAR, WHIP, and ERA. Sale has been one of the most dominant pitchers because of his arm angle, fastball, and curveball. He has been the best pitcher in the AL this season and should be rewarded by starting the All-Star game.

Max Scherzer

Max Scherzer
Max Scherzer

Good or Bad: Good

Although Max does not have a great ERA, 3.02, he is off to a historic start because of his 13 wins and zero losses. Scherzer is a strikeout pitcher and his stats back up that notation. Max is second in both WHIP and strikeouts, which shows how dominant a pitcher he can be. Max is definitely worthy of this All-Star selection.

Justin Verlander

Justin Verlander
Justin Verlander

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Derek Holland

Derek Holland
Derek Holland

Although Verlander has been the best pitcher over the last few years, he is not deserving of being on this roster. Verlander’s ERA, WHIP, and WAR are not impressive, ranked 15th, 29th, and 14th respectively. Verlander is not even top 5 in strikeouts, which is his specialty. Holland should be playing in the All-Star game. Holland has a better WHIP, ERA, and WAR than Verlander. Holland should be pitching in this All-Star game.

Relief Pitches:

Brett Cecil

Brett Cecil
Brett Cecil

Good or Bad: Good

The AL will need a lefty specialist to strikeout some of the dangerous lefty hitters. Cecil is having a dominant season, 0.87 WHIP, 1.81 ERA, 52 K, and 44.2 innings. Cecil has five holds and has been one of the best middle relievers in the AL. He will be a very important part of AL roster.

Jesse Crain

Jesse Crain
Jesse Crain

Good or Bad: Bad

Replacement: Greg Holland

Greg Holland
Greg Holland

Although Crain is having a great season, the relievers on the All-Star team should be closers. Between Crain and Cecil, I believe that Cecil should be selected for the team. There are closers that have similar numbers to Crain, but they pitch in more pressure situations. Pus Crain is presently on the DL. Greg Holland is having a great season for the Royals. Since he can be the Royals All-Star representative, a spot would open for a more deserving candidate than Salvador Perez. Holland is a deserving pitcher because of his 0.94 WHIP and 1.91 ERA. Holland is 20 for 22 and has a hold. However, the best stat is his strikeout numbers. Holland has struck out 56 batters in 33 innings, 15.3 strikeouts per 9 innings, which is ridiculous.

Joe Nathan

Joe Nathan
Joe Nathan

Good or Bad: Good

Nathan is tied for second in the AL in saves with Mariano Rivera. Nathan is having the best season of any reliever in MLB. Nathan has a WHIP of 0.78 and an ERA of 1.40. Nathan has blown only one save in 30 opportunities. Nathan should be the eighth inning man because of the great first half he had.

Glen Perkins

Glen Perkins
Glen Perkins

Good or Bad: Good

Perkins is one of the few bright spots on the Minnesota Twins. Perkins is having a really good season, 20 saves, 0.77 WHIP, and 1.93 ERA. Even though the Twins rarely have a lead, they almost always win if they have a lead going into the ninth. Perkins is a deserving candidate to pitch at the Mid Summer Classic.

Mariano Rivera

Mariano Riviera
Mariano Rivera

Good or Bad: Good

The greatest reliever of all time and possibly the greatest pitcher ever should enjoy his last All-Star appearance. He is having a great season, 29 saves, 1.89 ERA, and 1.29 WHIP. He is the most reliable and consistent reliever of all time, especially during the most pressure filled situations. Leyland should be calling on him if the AL has a one run lead in the ninth.

 

Stats and pics from espn.com